Searches for “help with mortgage” are higher than 2008 financial crisis levels

by

The wannabe real estate moguls going bust

Mom-and-pop landlords built real estate empires using under-the-radar DSCR loans. Now it’s coming back to bite them.

Applying for a home loan is a pain. You have to produce a heap of documents — bank statements, tax returns, employment records, tallies of investment accounts — to prove the stability of your financial footing, then wait for a mortgage underwriter to comb through all of it before giving you the thumbs up. I spoke with one exasperated homebuyer who described the process as a “borderline invasion of privacy.”

While the average American submits to a financial colonoscopy en route to their dream home, wannabe real estate moguls have found a way to sidestep the hassle. With the help of a once-obscure type of loan, they’ve built mini-empires ranging from a few homes to a few hundred — without the usual scrutiny from lenders. These landlords include small-time investors eager to expand their portfolios, TikTok tycoons seeking new streams of real estate revenue, and seasoned property managers looking to make smart bets. In recent years, they’ve taken out billions of dollars’ worth of “debt-service coverage ratio” loans — often abbreviated as DSCR — to hoover up homes. The loans enable income-seeking owners to quickly purchase rental properties while dodging annoying questions about their job history or outstanding debts. DSCRs may sound complicated, but obtaining one is relatively straightforward: A landlord just has to show their lender that the desired property will generate enough rent to cover the monthly payments and other basic expenses, such as taxes and insurance. The lender focuses on the property’s cash flow, not the borrower’s personal creditworthiness.

For some of these landlords, the cash isn’t flowing as planned. Serious delinquencies on DSCR loans have nearly quadrupled in the past three years, data from the real estate analytics firm Cotality shows. Although the troubled loans account for only a small fraction of the total dollar amount of outstanding DSCR loans, they’re a sign that debt-laden landlords face shakier economics amid a rental market slowdown. And while people in the industry defend the idea behind the loans — “It’s still a great product,” one lending veteran tells me — they acknowledge the spread of some sketchy practices that contributed to the spike in bad debt, including ambitious rent targets, hasty approvals, and loans for properties where the rental income wouldn’t even cover the basic monthly payments.

Despite all the hand-wringing over Wall Street-backed giants gobbling up homes, it’s the small and midsize players — prime candidates for DSCR loans — that make up the lion’s share of investor purchases. If lenders tighten their standards in response to the recent turbulence, that could mean fewer budding land barons angling for houses. Regular buyers might benefit from less competition for available homes or the forced sales of some of these places. But a little shakiness in the short term doesn’t mean these loans, along with the investors seeking real estate riches, will disappear. Big asset managers, keen on putting their money to work in real estate, have embraced the product. And with more people turning to rentals instead of buying, more landlords will take on this debt to multiply their holdings — even if some of their dreams of building real estate kingdoms come crumbling down.

h/t TonyLiberty