If the Supreme Court Rejects Trump’s Tariffs, How Big Might Refunds Be?

Authored by Mike Shedlock via mishtalk,

US customs trade data, compared to Trump’s Truth Social claim. Possible decision January 14.

Total tariffs and IEEPA tariffs through 2026-01-12

It’s the IEEPA tariffs that are under Supreme Court review.

Total rebates, if they happened yesterday, would be 93.15 billion for fiscal year 2025 plus 40.36 billion for fiscal year 2026.

That total is 133.5 billion, rising daily.

This is highly speculative, but we may have a ruling on Wednesday, January 14.

Trump’s Claim

Truth Social Link: The actual numbers that we would have to pay back if, for any reason, the Supreme Court were to rule against the United States of America on Tariffs, would be many Hundreds of Billions of Dollars, and that doesn’t include the amount of “payback” that Countries and Companies would require for the Investments they are making on building Plants, Factories, and Equipment, for the purpose of being able to avoid the payment of TariffsWhen these Investments are added, we are talking about Trillions of Dollars! It would be a complete mess, and almost impossible for our Country to pay. Anybody who says that it can be quickly and easily done would be making a false, inaccurate, or totally misunderstood answer to this very large and complex question. It may not be possible but, if it were, it would be Dollars that would be so large that it would take many years to figure out what number we are talking about and even, who, when, and where, to pay. Remember, when America shines brightly, the World shines brightly. In other words, if the Supreme Court rules against the United States of America on this National Security bonanza, WE’RE SCREWED!

PRESIDENT DONALD J. TRUMP

Big Set of Trumpian Lies

The cumulative IEEPA total to date is 133.5 billion.

Trump’s claim “that doesn’t include the amount of “payback” that Countries and Companies would require for the Investments they are making on building Plants, Factories, and Equipment” is nonsense.

Those are wildly exaggerated unsecured pledges and mostly rebutted by source. Importantly, those are private investments, not US Treasury receipts.

Nothing was collected and there would be zero rebates.

IEEPA Tariff Breakdowns

IEEPA tariffs through 2026-01-12

Tariff Remedy Enforcement by Fiscal Year

Total tariffs by classification section through 2026-01-12

Section 232 Tariffs

Section 232 Tariffs through 2026-01-12

Trump’s statement “it would be Dollars that would be so large that it would take many years to figure out what number we are talking about and even, who, when, and where, to pay,” is a blatant lie.

The idea we are collecting tariffs and don’t even know how much is laughable. The numbers on my charts are published administration numbers.

On the assumption that customs knows who it collected money from, the process is simple. Rebate the IEEPA tariff money collected. The administration has details for every category, updated daily.

The administration’s bragging by category proves they are lying about the difficulty of rebates.

Of course, one cannot possibly underestimate the potential stupidity of this administration.

If the Administration insisted, it could do things on a receipt-by-receipt basis. Then the administration would have mountains of paperwork to deal with.