Traditional female genital practices, though long-standing in many cultures, have become the focus of an expansive global campaign against ‘female genital mutilation’ (FGM). In this article, we critically examine the harms produced by the anti-FGM discourse and policies, despite their grounding in human rights and health advocacy. We argue that a ubiquitous ‘standard tale’ obscures the diversity of practices, meanings and experiences among those affected. This discourse, driven by a heavily racialised and ethnocentric framework, has led to unintended but serious consequences: the erosion of trust in healthcare settings, the silencing of dissenting or nuanced community voices, racial profiling and disproportionate legal surveillance of migrant families. Moreover, we highlight a troubling double standard that legitimises comparable genital surgeries in Western contexts while condemning similar procedures in others. We call for more balanced and evidence-based journalism, policy and public discourse—ones that account for cultural complexity and avoid the reductive and stigmatising force of the term ‘mutilation’. A re-evaluation of advocacy strategies is needed to ensure that they do not reproduce the very injustices they aim to challenge.
https://jme.bmj.com/content/early/2025/12/14/jme-2025-110961
BREAKING: The @bmj_latest – whose chief editor is @KamranAbbasi – has published an article asking for criticism of female genital mutilation to be softened.
There is ZERO excuse for this.
See the next tweet to see what Abbasi thinks about COVID vaccine harms and Israel. https://t.co/MsaysO4gwV
— Jikkyleaks 🐭 (@Jikkyleaks) December 16, 2025
Yahoo News UK summarized the paper as “a research paper that defends female genital mutilation,” noting it argued that condemnation is based on “misleading, often racialised stereotypes” and “Western sensationalism”
https://uk.news.yahoo.com/female-genital-mutilation-abuse-suggesting-193459752.html
“The British Medical Journal Group has published an article defending female genital mutilation… Researchers claim the phrase ‘mutilation’ is stigmatising.”
h/t A Deplorable Neanderthal